I suspect the effect of the Asbury Revival will fade rather quickly. But I also suspect that there were certain participants who were deeply touched, and whose lives will have been changed. Over the decades, I have attended a number of local revivals. I would also note that renewal weekends, such as Cursillo and Emmaus, in many ways are mini revivals. Most people are extremely touched by what they experience.

One of the ways I measure whether a true revival has taken place, as opposed to a momentary awakening, is how durable the change is in the behavior of the participants. In renewal ministry. this is generally less than 20%, even over the short term, based upon those who continue to engage in intentional ministry or attend reunions to reinforce what they have learned. Most consider it a wonderful experience, but not really life-changing over the long run.

I think the most important thing to consider is whether it changed anyone’s life. I think in many cases a select few had a dramatic transformation. I suspect this also occurred during the Asbury Revival. While it may not be a revival along the lines of the events in Acts, even changing the hearts and minds of a few is a reason for celebration. I applaud any event which furthers the kingdom of God. In that sense, it was authentic for that handful who in fact were touched and changed.